We compared more than 20 rental desks at Istanbul Airport (IST), Sabiha Gökçen (SAW) and in the city, using Google ratings, review volume and recency, and complaint records on Şikayetvar. This is the first stage: three companies, each with who it suits and when it does not.
This pick rests on evidence from thousands of real customers, not on a one-off test of our own: how their Google ratings are spread, the topics they mention most, and their published complaints on Şikayetvar.
1
★ Best overall
Çizgi Rent a Car
Turkish company since 1991 (Mızraklı Group), desks inside both airports
Enterprise or Alamo members, and anyone landing at IST who wants familiar procedures.
Not for you if you are
Anyone who may need fast follow-up on a complaint after the rental; its Şikayetvar response rate is low.
What customers say: the evidence in numbers
Istanbul Airport IST (1,216)87% 5 stars · 10% 1 star
Sabiha Gökçen SAW (1,232)79% 5 stars · 16% 1 star
Most mentioned by customers (Google review topics):
Polite staff: 29 reviews
Car cleanliness: 20
Quick processing: 14
At SAW about one customer in six gives one star, often citing pressure to buy extra insurance or the booked car not being available. On Şikayetvar, complaint-resolution satisfaction is 47/100.
Pros
Highest-rated global brand at Istanbul Airport
Reviews mention accepting cards other firms refused, and free upgrades
Staff patient with non-Turkish speakers, according to reviews
Cons and warnings
Weaker at SAW: complaints about pressure to buy extra insurance
47/100 complaint-resolution satisfaction on Şikayetvar, mostly about confirmed bookings not honoured
Very low reply rate to complaints on Şikayetvar
3
★ For city pick-up
Garenta
Large Turkish network; its best branches are in the city, not at IST
Residents and visitors who want a car for a few days from a nearby city branch, booking directly with the company.
Not for you if you are
Anyone booking through Booking.com or other brokers, or collecting at IST.
What customers say: the evidence in numbers
Yenibosna (2,775)87% 5 stars · 7% 1 star
Istanbul Airport IST (506)66% 5 stars · 29% 1 star
Most mentioned by customers (Google review topics):
Attentive staff: 535 reviews (Yenibosna)
Car cleanliness: 77
New cars: 29
Deposit refund: 14 (airport)
Booking process: 11 (airport)
Branches differ sharply: 7% one-star ratings in Yenibosna versus nearly 3 in 10 at Istanbul Airport. That is why we recommend it for city branches only.
Pros
City branches with high ratings and thousands of reviews
Wide choice of cars; quick pick-up and return, per reviews
Direct online booking
Cons and warnings
The IST airport branch is rated only 3.7
Repeated recent complaints of Booking.com reservations being refused, then a higher price offered
Complaints about slow deposit refunds and bookings cancelled after resident credit checks
Desks rated low right now: be careful before booking
Your licenceTourists can drive in Türkiye on their home licence for up to 6 months after entry; an International Driving Permit is advised, especially for licences not in Latin script. Many companies require the licence to be one or two years old.
Card and depositUse a credit card in the driver's own name. A deposit is held on the card and usually released within weeks; ask the amount and the release time before you sign.
Booking through brokersIf you booked through Booking.com or another broker, print the confirmation and terms, and check that the branch accepts that broker's bookings.
Photograph the carPhotograph the car on every side, plus the fuel gauge and mileage, at pick-up and return; most disputes are about damage and fuel.
Motorway and bridge tollsMotorways and bridges are paid through the HGS tag in the car and charged to your card later; ask for the toll statement at return.
How this pick was made
Figures are a snapshot of Google Maps and Şikayetvar on the check date above and may change. The evidence is aggregated from thousands of reviews, not quotes from individual ones. Pros and cons are our own summary of recent customer reviews and complaints. No company paid us or pays us commission, and the links here are map links for checking, not booking links.